Bereishit 47:28-50:26 - Fear Not
As we complete the book of Bereishit, Bereishit, this week, Jacob has died, and the brothers now turn to Joseph and say, “Our father asked us to beg you to forgive us for what we did to you” (Bereishit 50:15-21 ). There is no evidence that Jacob actually said that, and it may simply be the brothers’ sense of guilt because Joseph had treated them well and showed no signs of bearing a grudge, after the initial tough encounter in Egypt. Joseph replied, “Have no fear, I'm not a substitute for G-D” and I guarantee I am going to take care of you.
I've always been interested in the way the word fear, is used in the Torah. The Hebrew word for fear is Yira. But like many words in the Torah, it has multiple meanings. It could mean the fear of someone or something. Or it could mean the fear of saying something wrong, inappropriate, or doing something wrong morally. This latter usage is associated with the word when the Torah talks about fear of G-D or fear of your mother and father. It doesn't mean to be frightened as in scared, it means one should be bound by the constraints either of morality or of a relationship with G-D.
Looking at the way the word is used in the Torah, illustrates these differences. When Sarah is told that she is going to have a child in her old age and she denies it, when confronted, The Torah says she was frightened of repercussions whether from Abraham or G-D (Bereishit 18:15). When Lot escapes from Sodom and flees to the town of Tsoar it says he was frightened to stay there (Genesis19:30 ). When Isaac is frightened for his safety he says, “I was frightened lest they kill me because of my wife” (Bereishit 26: 6). And Jacob says to Laban “I was frightened that you were going to steal my daughters away from me (Bereishit 31:31). And again, before his encounter with Esau he says, “ I am frightened that he will come and kill me and my children” (Bereishit 32:12). These are all examples of physical fear.
And there is another example that refers to fear of G-D or moral dereliction. The two midwives in Egypt did not kill the Israelite boys because they feared G-D, not because they feared Pharaoh (Shemot 1:21). Twice in the context of the Sinai Revelation the word fear is used. The first time (20:17) is when Moses tells the people not to be afraid of the powerful phenomenon of Sinai on fire. And the second is when he comes down the mountain with the second set of tablets and his face is shining so brightly that the people are afraid to approach him, and he wears a mask (34:30). What kind of fear was that?
Returning to Bereishit, twice the phrase “Pachad Yitzchak” is used. It could mean ‘fear of Isaac,’ or ‘Isaac’s fear of G-D.’ Interesting that it is Isaac to whom the description Pachad Yitzhak, is used in Bereishit Chapter 31. Which can either mean that Isaac feared G-D or that he was subservient to G-D. But then why say this only of Isaac and not Abraham or Jacob? Unless it is meant to convey something unique about Isaac’s relationship with G-D. Or to be cynical because he was traumatized by his near sacrifice on Mount Moriah.
I have always thought it unsatisfactory to translate the word Yira as fear in every case. When applied to G-D I believe that we should not translate it as fear at all, but as respect or even awe. Particularly in our mystical tradition the relationship with G-D is seen as something comforting, reassuring, and caring, rather than frightening and distant.
The Book of Bereishit, Bereishit, ends with the death of Joseph. When Jacob died, he was given a state funeral, and his body was conducted by his family and by the dignitaries of Egypt to The Cave of Machpelah in Hebron where he was buried. Yes, Israel has a long association with Hebron going back thousands of years. In the case of Joseph, we are told he was placed in a box in Egypt. The contrast is striking. The lives of the fathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were ones of constant challenge, danger, and difficulties. Throughout them all they struggled in every area, and yet still prospered. In the case of Joseph after the initial struggle that he had with his brothers, he ends up in a position of complete safety, of power, authority, and respect. And yet within a short time, things changed so dramatically as we see in the book of Shemot, and he is forgotten.
The message that resonates with the present moment is that we have always to be worried about the challenges and the threats and the dangers that we face. And not take our safety for granted. We should be examples of Pachad in one sense, insecurity. We never know what challenges we will have to face. But the way to respond is by having faith, a belief in the future, and a relationship with G-D this is better described as one of respect and devotion than one of fear.
Shabbat Shalom
Jeremy