We Mistook Getting Used to It for Progress
We Mistook Getting Used to It for Progress

I had TalkTV playing in the background on YouTube while I worked. The discussion was about what social media, short videos, endless scrolling and a constant supply of news are doing to young people and to the rest of us. One of the guests reached for a familiar argument. People warned us about the cinema, he said. They warned us about radio, television and the internet. Now they are warning us about social media. He seemed to find the whole thing faintly ridiculous.

What struck me was how casually he assumed that the people who warned us before had been proved wrong. When did we establish that? Each of those technologies became part of ordinary life. We carried on working, raising families and going about our business. What do those facts tell us about the habits we acquired along the way, or about those we gave up?

What We Got Used To

Support Independent Journalism and Advertise Here to Reach Readers Around the World

Consider how the demands on our attention have changed. Going to the cinema meant going somewhere. Radio and television brought programmes into the home. Rolling news meant there was always a bulletin to watch, even when there was very little to add. The internet made it possible to look up almost anything whenever we wanted. The smartphone brought all of this into the pocket, and the feed took away even the small effort of deciding what to look for. There is already something waiting when we open it, and something else waiting when we finish.

At every stage there was something worth having. I was listening to a discussion about the dangers of digital media on YouTube while I worked. It had already become ordinary for me to fill the room with somebody else’s conversation while doing something that needed my attention. I scarcely thought about that until the guest said something that made me stop working and listen.

That is how a change in habit can escape our notice. There was time at each stage to ask what had been displaced and to recover some of it. Instead, by the time the next advance arrived, we had usually grown accustomed to what the previous one demanded of us. The next change was judged against the life we were already living. What would once have seemed an extraordinary intrusion arrived as a small addition to an ordinary day.

The Whole World in the Room

Social media is only part of this. A person can give up every social media account and still spend much of the day moving from news alerts to video clips to live discussion of events thousands of miles away. A tragedy breaks in the morning. By lunchtime we have seen the footage, heard the speculation and watched strangers quarrel about who is to blame. Before supper we are being asked to give the same attention to something else.

SpudsToGo ® — The Brand You Already Know ™

There are events we need to know about and circumstances in which knowing allows us to help. Much of what comes across the screen asks nothing of us beyond looking again. We begin to feel that we owe every tragedy our grief, every allegation our judgement and every controversy an opinion. We can spend an evening thinking about people whose names we learnt that morning and give scarcely a thought to someone in our own family who has been having a difficult week.

Children are growing up among adults who already live this way. A parent can tell a child to put away the phone, then reach for their own as soon as the conversation pauses. A child can see how quickly we abandon a book, a meal or even a conversation with them when something lights up on the table. We have given young people a great deal of instruction about the dangers of screens. They have also had years to watch what we are willing to interrupt for one.

How Would We Know What We Had Lost?

The image of the boiling frog comes to mind because the temperature rises by degrees. In the fable, at least, the ending settles any argument about what happened. A society can carry on for a very long time while its members grow less accustomed to giving one another their full attention. People born into that society may know very little of the ordinary life against which an earlier generation could have measured the change. By then, even the suggestion that something was lost can sound like nostalgia.

I believe we are living through a gradual deterioration in the way we give our attention, conduct our relationships and understand what deserves our concern. I doubt we can recover much of what we have already surrendered. A family can put its phones away at dinner. It is harder to restore a common expectation that the people at the table should have first claim on one another’s attention, especially when breaking that expectation has become so unremarkable.

The next technology will arrive in a society that has already learnt to live with all of this. Its first demands may seem modest. We will measure them against the interruptions we already accept, the hours we already spend looking at a screen and the amount of the world’s distress we already carry into our homes. And when someone asks whether we can afford to give up a little more, there will always be somebody ready to point out that people raised the same objection last time.