
There is a peculiar contradiction in modern society. We claim to value freedom of expression, yet increasingly demand that people apologise for the words they use, the opinions they hold and even the thoughts we imagine they might possess. We have become a society preoccupied with offence, where an ill-chosen word can generate days of public outrage, condemnation and demands for repentance.
For Jews, this phenomenon has produced an entire industry devoted to combating antisemitism. Organisations monitor language, catalogue insults, issue condemnations and demand apologies. Politicians are encouraged to make declarations, institutions are pressured to adopt definitions, and individuals are publicly chastised for expressions considered offensive to the Jewish community.
Yet I find myself asking a rather simple question: What, precisely, are we accomplishing?
Are we eliminating Jew hatred, or are we merely teaching those who hate us to conceal their feelings?
I have long maintained a position that some within our own community may find uncomfortable:
“We won’t combat Jew Hatred by focusing on the hatred. Rather, non-attention is how it should be handled. Do not allow it to occupy your time, nor to become a focal point of any kind. It is a rule that Esau hates Jacob.”
— Rami ben Ze'ev
My position is not that Jew hatred does not exist, nor that it presents no danger. Quite the contrary. I recognise its existence, its persistence throughout history and the very real consequences it has brought upon our people.
What I reject is the proposition that we should organise our lives around it.
An Apology Nobody Needed to Demand
On 20 November 2026, Page Six reported that Bowen Yang, formerly of Saturday Night Live, had apologised for describing Jewish singer Regina Spektor as a “Zio” during an episode of the Las Culturistas podcast.
Apparently, the word is considered an antisemitic slur because of its association with David Duke and other figures within white supremacist movements.
I confess that until encountering this article, I had never heard the expression.
Yang explained that he had not known its antisemitic history and expressed regret at having adopted language associated with far-right movements.
Having issued his apology, he then published another Instagram Story declaring:
“At the same time, Free Palestine.”
I found this sequence rather revealing, although perhaps not for the reasons others might expect.
Firstly, I would never have demanded an apology from Yang. Indeed, I would not have wanted one.
If Yang wishes to use the word “Zio”, let him. If he wishes to criticise Zionism, let him. If he wishes to express hostility towards Jews, he should be free to express that opinion too.
I do not require his approval, his affection or his validation of my Jewish identity.
Secondly, his subsequent declaration about Palestine raises an interesting question. Why did he consider it necessary to follow an apology concerning language directed towards a Jewish woman with a political declaration about the Israeli-Arab conflict?
The two matters are not interchangeable.
The historical and political questions surrounding the Land of Israel, Jewish sovereignty, Arab national identity and the modern conflict are complex. The name Palestine has a long geographical history, including its use during the British Mandate, when Jews themselves were also described as Palestinians. Golda Meir famously recalled that she had been Palestinian before the establishment of the modern State of Israel.
The Palestine Liberation Organization, established in 1964, subsequently became a principal representative of Arab nationalism, in Israel, although that brand of national identity had developed before the organisation's creation.
None of this establishes what Bowen Yang personally believes about Jews generally, nor does his political slogan alone prove that he hates us.
But it does illustrate the ease with which a discussion supposedly concerned with offensive language becomes entangled with political declarations, collective identities and the expectation that everyone must publicly demonstrate the correct position.
As far as I am concerned, Yang was entitled to make both statements.
He was also entitled not to apologise at all.
The question is why we have created a society in which an apology is considered necessary whenever someone takes offence.
Thank You for Noticing
Some years ago, I was travelling on a tram in Blackpool, England, wearing my kippah.
A man looked at me with an unmistakably menacing expression and uttered a single word:
“Jew...”
There was no ambiguity about his tone. He was not enquiring about my identity or attempting to begin a friendly conversation. He intended the word as an insult.
I looked at him and replied:
“Thank you for noticing!”
And that was the end of the matter.
He had intended to diminish me by identifying me as a Jew. I had thanked him for recognising something of which I am neither ashamed nor embarrassed.
Why should I have been offended?
I am a Jew. His observation was entirely correct.
The contempt with which he delivered it belonged to him, not to me.
I could have become angry. I could have demanded an apology, reported the incident or spent the remainder of my journey contemplating the hatred that had apparently motivated his remark.
Instead, I continued with my day.
I did not require the man to change his opinion. I did not require him to like Jews. I did not even require him to conceal his dislike.
Indeed, I would rather know what he thought.
A person who openly expresses hatred allows me to recognise him for who he is. A person compelled to conceal that hatred may present an entirely different face.
That distinction matters.
The Danger of Driving Hatred Underground
There is a widespread assumption that prohibiting offensive expressions will somehow reduce the prejudice behind them.
I question that assumption.
A man who despises Jews does not cease despising Jews because someone tells him that a particular word is unacceptable. He may simply learn to employ another expression, conceal his views or reserve them for private company.
His words may change while his convictions remain untouched.
Worse, the experience of being publicly condemned or compelled to apologise may itself deepen his resentment.
This is not to suggest that every restriction necessarily produces greater hatred. Human behaviour is more complicated than that. But we should not confuse the suppression of language with the transformation of character.
I would rather encounter someone who openly declares his contempt for Jews than someone who has learned to disguise that contempt behind socially acceptable language.
At least with the former, I know where I stand.
This is not an argument against protecting people from genuine threats, harassment or violence. Those are matters of conduct and public safety, not merely questions of personal offence.
It is an argument against believing that we can legislate, shame or intimidate hatred out of the human heart.
We cannot compel another person to love us.
And why should we wish to?
Esav and Yaakov (Esau and Jacob)
Our Sages recognised the persistence of hostility towards the Jewish people long before modern political movements, social media platforms or organisations dedicated to combating antisemitism existed.
In Sifrei Bemidbar 69, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai teaches:
הלכה עשו שונא ליעקב
“It is an established principle that Esav hates Yaakov.”
The teaching arises from the account of the meeting between Esav and Yaakov in Bereshit 33:4.
It is important to understand that the Sages were not presenting a modern racial theory, nor should their words be employed to declare every non-Jew an enemy. Indeed, the same discussion recognises that Esav's compassion was stirred at that moment and that he embraced his brother wholeheartedly.
Nevertheless, the teaching recognises an enduring pattern of hostility that has accompanied Jewish history.
Our people have experienced persecution under successive kingdoms, empires, religious authorities and political movements. The language and justifications have changed, but hostility towards Jews has repeatedly resurfaced.
I do not believe that another campaign, another public apology or another carefully drafted definition of antisemitism will finally bring this history to an end.
Nor do I believe that the Jewish people should spend their existence attempting to persuade the world to love them.
We have a far more important purpose.
We have Torah.
We have obligations to Hashem, to our families, to our communities and to one another.
These obligations do not disappear because someone somewhere has expressed an unpleasant opinion about Jews.
Why, then, should that opinion become the centre of our attention?
Trust in G-D, but Lock Your Door
There is an expression I particularly favour:
“Trust in G-D, but lock your door.”
It expresses a fundamental distinction between faith and carelessness.
When Yaakov prepared to meet Esav, he did not simply disregard the possibility of danger. In Bereshit 32, he prayed to Hashem, divided his camp and made practical preparations.
He trusted Hashem, but he also acted responsibly.
We should do likewise.
If someone threatens violence, we take appropriate precautions. If our families or communities face genuine danger, we protect them. If there is a credible threat to a synagogue, we do not leave its doors unlocked merely to demonstrate our faith.
But none of this requires us to become emotionally consumed by the hatred of others.
There is an enormous difference between recognising danger and living in perpetual anticipation of it.
There is an equally important distinction between taking reasonable precautions against another person's actions and attempting to control his opinions.
I have no desire to live in fear of what someone might say about me.
Nor do I wish to surrender my peace of mind to the prejudices of strangers.
We can lock our doors without allowing hatred to occupy our homes.
Faith, Anger and the Limits of Our Control
There is also a theological dimension to this question that I believe is too frequently overlooked.
Nothing occurs beyond Hashem's knowledge or outside the scope of Divine Providence.
This does not mean that every human action is righteous or that Hashem approves of every choice a person makes. The Torah clearly distinguishes between permitted and forbidden conduct, and human beings remain responsible for their actions.
But it does mean that we should be cautious about allowing anger at the conduct of others to overwhelm our trust in Hashem.
If someone insults me, what has actually changed?
Has my Jewish identity diminished?
Has my relationship with Hashem been weakened?
Has the Torah become less true because a stranger has spoken contemptuously about Jews?
Of course not.
The insult has revealed something about the speaker. It has not altered the person to whom it was directed.
Our Sages teach in Pirkei Avot 4:1:
איזהו גבור הכובש את יצרו
“Who is mighty? One who conquers his inclination.”
We commonly understand strength in terms of the ability to confront an adversary, defeat an opponent or compel another person to submit.
Yet the Sages direct our attention inward.
The person who governs his own inclinations possesses a form of strength that cannot be obtained through the control of others.
I do not need to silence a man who hates Jews to demonstrate that I am secure in my Jewish identity.
I need only refuse to allow his hatred to govern my conduct.
The Industry of Fighting Antisemitism
This brings me to a subject that I know will be controversial.
I question the methods and effectiveness of the many organisations whose principal purpose is to combat antisemitism.
I do not question that some individuals working within these organisations are sincere, nor do I dismiss the importance of documenting genuine threats, assisting victims or protecting Jewish institutions.
But I do question whether the constant monitoring, amplification and condemnation of offensive language is producing the results these organisations claim to seek.
Every offensive remark becomes a headline. Every unfortunate expression becomes a controversy. Every celebrity apology becomes an occasion for another round of public declarations.
And throughout this process, Jew hatred receives precisely what it so often seeks: attention.
We should ask whether these campaigns are changing hearts, protecting lives or merely sustaining an endless cycle of offence and reaction.
We should also be willing to examine the leadership, funding, priorities and accountability of organisations claiming to speak on behalf of Jewish communities.
No organisation should be presumed to represent every Jew simply because it describes itself as fighting antisemitism.
I certainly do not authorise anyone to be offended on my behalf.
Nor do I wish to be told that I must regard a particular word as an injury simply because an organisation has determined that it should be treated as such.
My Jewish identity is not theirs to administer.
Let Them Speak
I return, finally, to Bowen Yang.
If he wishes to call someone a “Zio”, let him speak.
If he wishes to declare “Free Palestine”, let him speak.
If someone wishes to express an opinion that I consider historically ignorant, morally objectionable or openly hostile towards Jews, I would still rather hear it than compel its concealment.
I can disagree. I can decline to associate with the speaker. I can challenge factual falsehoods when there is a worthwhile reason to do so.
Or I can simply continue with my life, refer to my article "Let’s Say You Do Nothing: Refusing the Habit of Outrage".
What I will not do is make another person's hatred the defining concern of my existence.
Jew hatred is older than the modern State of Israel, older than Zionism, older than Christianity and Islam, and older than the political movements that presently employ it.
Within our religious understanding, the hostility represented by Esav and Yaakov has accompanied the Jewish people across generations. I do not expect that history to be overturned by a social media campaign, a public apology or the adoption of new rules governing acceptable speech.
I look towards the coming of Mashiach, not towards a world perfected by the censorship of human opinions.
Until then, we have a responsibility to live faithfully, act prudently and fulfil our obligations under Torah.
We need not invite hatred into our homes, our thoughts or our daily lives merely because it exists beyond our doors.
Let those who hate us express themselves.
Let us recognise them, take whatever precautions are necessary and continue with the work Hashem has placed before us.
Our Jewishness is not a response to antisemitism. It is an identity, a responsibility and a covenant that existed long before those who presently despise us, and will endure long after they are gone.
And should someone look at me with contempt and utter the word “Jew”, my answer will remain the same:
“Thank you for noticing!”